Mar, 2020 this chapter evaluates jon elsters sour grapes. Sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the study of forms of irrationality. Tore sandven 1999 philosophy of the social sciences 29 2. Explaining social behavior offers a highly readable and highly opinionated introduction to jon elsters theory of social scientific explanation. Aug 26, 2009 two philosophers, jeanpaul sartre and jon elster, have taken great interest in the famous childrens fable, the fox and the grapes. In the first part of the chapter, elsters work is put in intellectual context. Studies in the subversion of rationality reprint by jon elster isbn. Books by jon elster author of explaining social behavior. Elster s characterisation of rationality leaves room for both forms of social explanation. Elster believes the fable teaches us that opportunities shapes desires while sartre contends it demonstrates how consciousness alleviates the frustrations associated with failure. In the 1970s, elster continued his work on explanations in the social sciences and rational choice theory in particular. Drawing on philosophy, political and social theory, decisiontheory, economics, psychology, history and literature, jon elster s classic book sour grapes continues and complements the arguments of his acclaimed earlier book, ulysses and the sirens.
Studies in the subversion of rationality cambridge. In this short book, he crystallizes and advances his work, bridging the gap between philosophers who use the idea of reason to assess human behavior from a normative point of view and. Jon elster wikipedia bahasa indonesia, ensiklopedia bebas. Pdf a critical discussion of jon elsters arguments. Sour grapes by jon elster cambridge university press. Studies in the subversion of rationality jon elster drawing on philosophy, political and social theory, decisiontheory, economics, psychology, history and literature, jon elsters classic book sour grapes continues and complements the arguments of his. Explaining technical change, cambridge university press 1983, pp. Sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the sour grapes. In sour grapes utilitarianism and the genesis of wants, jon elster delineates the problem of adaptive preference formation by comparing it with other mechanisms of preference change that are closely related to it and are often confused with it. Studies in the subversion of rationality, authorjon elster, year1983.
Autonomy, adaptation, and rationalitya critical discussion of jon elster s concept of sour grapes, part ii. This book is expansive, offering not only a general theory of scientific explanation, but also a theory of mind, a theory of social norms, a theory of. Studies in the subversion of rationality cambridge, a book by jon elster. Studies in the subversion of rationality jon elster. These essays continue and complement the arguments of jon elsters earlier book, ulysses and the sirens. Studies in the subversion of rationality, a 1983 book by jon elster sour grapes, a song by puscifer from v is for vagina. Elsters characterisation of rationality leaves room for both forms of social explanation. Studies in the subversion of rationality thirtyfive years after publication. At the same general level, the idea that less is more is susceptible. Studies in the subversion of rationality jon elster on amazon.
Dr elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, to provide the background and terms for the subsequent discussions, which cover irrational. The power of grapew these essays continue and complement the arguments of jon elster s earlier book, ulysses and the sirens. His books include ulysses and the sirens 1979, sour grapes 1983, making sense of marx 1985, the cement of society 1989, solomonic judgments. He is also a notable proponent of analytical marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and.
Jon elsters most popular book is explaining social behavior. In sour grapes elster 1983 analyzes the capacity for selfdeceit, which the agents have by citing the fable in which the fox, being unable to reach the grapes, says that they are worthless. Pdf on apr 1, 1999, hans o melberg and others published a critical discussion of jon elsters arguments about rational choice, infinite regress and the collection of information find, read and. Jon elster has 73 books on goodreads with 4169 ratings.
Elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, before tackling the notions of. Studies in the subversion of rationality thirty five years after publication. Making sense of marx studies in marxism and social theory. Oct 24, 2019 this chapter evaluates jon elsters sour grapes. Autonomy, adaptation, and rationalitya critical discussion of jon elsters concept of sour grapes, part i tore sandven philosophy of the social sciences 2016 29. Sour grapes poetry collection, a book of poems by william carlos williams. In sour grapes elster 1983 analyzes the capacity for self. I was a jon elster editor be the first to ask a question about ulysses and the sirens. Sep 01, 2019 jon elster, nuts and bolts for the social sciences philpapers sarah hailey rated it really liked it feb 12, elster has the guts to systematically show that we know more about human behavior than is generally believed but not nearly as much as most professionals in the field claim. These essays draw on philosophy, political and social theory, decisiontheory, economics and psychology as well as history and literature. Sour grapes, an expression from the fox and the grapes, one of aesops fablessour grapes, a film by larry david. Dr elster analyses the notation of rationality through the study of forms of irrationality, which cover irrational behaviour, irrational desires and irrational belief. Dr elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, to provide the background and terms for the subsequent discussions, which cover irrational behaviour, irrational desires and irrational belief. Click download or read online button to sourgrapes book pdf for free now.
The chapter draws attention to the significance of elsters framework in changing our understanding and scope of rational choice. Elster claims that we cannot know which conditions will trigger conformism or anticonformism, wishful thinking or counterwishful countermotivated thinking, adaptive preferences sour grapes or counteradaptive preferences the grass is greener p. With his books logic and society 1978, forklaring og dialektikk explanation and dialectics 1979, ulysses and the sirens 1979, explaining technical change 1983, and sour grapes. Nov 07, 2019 sour grapes aims to subvert orthodox theories of rational choice through the sour grapes.
One of the worlds most important political philosophers, jon elster is a leading thinker on reason and rationality and their roles in politics and public life. His publications include ulysses and the sirens 1979, sour grapes 1983, making sense of marx 1985, the cement of society 1989, solomonic judgements 1989, nuts and bolts for the social sciences 1989, local justice 1992 and political psychology 1993. Cambridge core political theory sour grapes by jon elster. These essays continue and complement the arguments of jon elsters earlier. Making sense of marx was a beautifully portioned book that is hard to praise adequately.
Autonomy, adaptation, and rationalitya critical discussion. Elster for economists salomon kalmanovitz in the highly specialized and formalized world of economics, it is refreshing to come across the ample and multidisciplinary work of jon elster. Two philosophers, jeanpaul sartre and jon elster, have taken great interest in the famous childrens fable, the fox and the grapes. The power of grapew these essays continue and complement the arguments of jon elsters earlier book, ulysses and the sirens. I claimed earlier that elster s work has some possibly very damaging implications for economics as a rational science, particularly economics done in the rational choice tradition. At the same general level, the idea that less is more is susceptible of another interpretation, namely, that ignorance is bliss. Jon elsters ulysses and the sirens is an outstandingly intelligent. Autonomy, adaptation, and rationalitya critical discussion of jon elsters concept of sour grapes, part ii tore sandven philosophy of the social sciences 1999 29. Their combined citations are counted only for the first article. In the first section of the chapter, elster s work is put in intellectual context. In sour grapes utilitarianism and the genesis of wants, jon elster delineates the prob lem of adaptive preference formation by comparing it. Elster begins with an analysis of the notation of rationality, before tackling the notions of irrational behavior, desires and belief with highly.
He is also a notable proponent of analytical marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and psychological grounds in 2016, he was awarded the 22nd. I would counter that this is correct to a certain extent, but that addictive products display a notable lack of demand elasticity although demand elstfr when prices rise, the reaction of demand to price is much less sensitive than it is with, say, pickles or. These, in the general case, are properties that cannot be immediately read off the wants themselves. Studies in the subversion of rationality, jon elster, cambridge. Drawing on philosophy, political and social theory, decisiontheory, economics, psychology, history and literature, jon elsters classic book sour grapes continues and complements the arguments of his acclaimed earlier book, ulysses and the sirens. He treats weakness of the will in a number of places. Jon elster has made his name among the best and brightest as one of the most usefull people in the social sciences. Jon elster lahir 22 februari 1940, oslo adalah teoriwan politik dan sosial norwegia yang telah menulis beberapa karya tentang filsafat ilmu sosial dan teori pilihan rasional. Pdf a critical discussion of jon elsters arguments about. Hobbes and the problem of sour grapes medium massage.
Studies in the subversion of rationality jon elster drawing on philosophy, political and social theory, decisiontheory, economics, psychology, history and literature, jon elster s classic book sour grapes continues and complements the arguments of his acclaimed earlier book, ulysses and the sirens. The chapter draws attention to the significance of elsters framework in changing our understanding and scope of rational choice theory. Such attitudes undermine the principle of rational choice which declares. Download pdf sourgrapes free online new books in politics. Ia juga merupakan pendukung marxisme analitis dan kritikus ekonomi neoklasik dan teori pilihan publik atas. Han er son av forfattar og kringkastingssjef torolf elster og lyrikar magli elster. Professor of political science, columbia university. Jon elster, nuts and bolts for the social sciences philpapers. Sour grapes jon elster sour grapes studies in the subversion of rationality. Studies in the subversion of rationality, author jon elster, year1983.
Elster nuts and bolts pdf within a brief compass, jon elster covers a vast range of topics. In the first section of the chapter, elsters work is put in intellectual context. Among the many reasons why this is so, i am only going to deal with three on this occasion. The chapter draws attention to the significance of elster s framework in changing our understanding and scope of rational choice theory. He is also a notable proponent of analytical marxism, and a critic of neoclassical economics and public choice theory, largely on behavioral and psychological grounds.
1104 165 1175 1474 222 952 803 371 1085 800 608 177 476 394 177 278 85 334 1466 1175 745 945 1173 1437 240 542 1318 594 461 973 614 1244 1208 1461 1032 1203 522 1198 996 191 1309 1172 929 448 1289 245 77 127